A little more than halfway through the season, “Presumed Innocent” delivers its much-anticipated supporting-character episode. As Rusty’s murder trial looms, Episode 5, titled “Pregame,” delves into the complex psyche of Tommy Molto, the prosecutor driven by an inexhaustible well of hatred. This episode is a staple in television series, akin to memorable supporting-character episodes in shows like “Girls” and “Seinfeld.”
The episode opens with Rusty in a heated confrontation with Brian Ratzer, followed by another tense explanation to Barbara. Soon after, we see Tommy scrutinizing Michael’s photos and videos from the night of Carolyn’s murder. He ominously notes “BIKE” in his notebook and zooms in on Carolyn’s bare legs. When Eugenia storms into his office, protesting her imminent call to the stand, Tommy insults her in three different ways: questioning if she has ever kissed Rusty, emphasizing “professional objectivity,” and threatening her job security. This interaction lasts just over a minute but sets the tone for Tommy’s character.
Tommy has largely remained in the shadows, both figuratively and literally. The closest glimpse into his inner self was in Episode 3, when Nico tore him apart in a bar booth. The camera’s framing kept Tommy mostly obstructed, signaling that his reaction to Nico’s criticism was less important than his endurance. Despite his short temper, Tommy takes a lot of flak from Nico, who treats him as a pawn. This dynamic reversal from the novel, where Rusty felt resentment towards Raymond, adds depth to Tommy’s character.
Back at the office, Tommy reminisces about Carolyn, revealing their strained relationship. Carolyn’s condescension towards Tommy is evident as she prefers working with Rusty for career reasons. Tommy’s wounded pride is palpable, and his expression mirrors the embarrassment of oversharing after a drunken night. This memory is interrupted by Nico, who initially trusts Tommy’s judgment but soon criticizes his impulsive press speech condemning the city’s lack of accountability. Nico’s infantilizing criticism pushes Tommy to finally stand up for himself, albeit with stammering and near tears. Tommy’s plea for respect and trust is a tour-de-force moment, showcasing his deep-seated need for validation.
Meanwhile, Barbara’s character also gains depth in “Pregame.” She finds herself drawn to Clifton, the bartender, and their interactions reveal her desire for respect and validation. Barbara’s confession to Dr. Rush about feeling relieved and desired by Clifton adds emotional layers to her character, making her more relatable and sympathetic.
Rusty, on the other hand, continues to make questionable decisions. He nearly breaks into Ratzer’s house and hides Kyle’s bicycle, a potential piece of evidence, in his car. His actions frustrate his defense team, Raymond and Mya, who are skeptical of his theories. As the trial approaches, Raymond’s confidence wavers, and he insists on Barbara testifying in Rusty’s favor. The night before the trial, the Sabiches hold hands, bracing for the challenges ahead.
Tommy’s opening statement in court is stirring, emphasizing the prosecutor’s humanity and the jury’s responsibility to justice. His rhetoric is compelling, making a strong case for the truth. Despite his flaws, Tommy’s legal prowess is undeniable, leaving Rusty visibly shaken.
Raymond’s nightmares continue to plague him, reflecting his inner turmoil. His dream of his head exploding is a particularly disturbing scene, reminiscent of David Cronenberg’s “Scanners.” This nightmare underscores the psychological toll the trial is taking on him.
Overall, “Pregame” is a pivotal episode that deepens our understanding of Tommy Molto and Barbara Sabich. It highlights their struggles for respect and validation, adding emotional complexity to their characters. As the trial begins, the stakes are higher than ever, and the characters’ vulnerabilities are laid bare.
Source: Vulture, Decider
