In the realm of action films, few premises are as thrilling as an attack on the White House. Two notable entries in this genre, “White House Down” and “Olympus Has Fallen,” both released in 2013, explore this concept with varying degrees of plausibility. The directors of these films faced a unique challenge: how to create tension and excitement while maintaining a believable narrative.
“White House Down,” directed by Roland Emmerich, presents a scenario where a former military operative leads a coup against the president. The film follows John Cale, a Capitol Police officer, who finds himself in the wrong place at the wrong time while interviewing for a job. As mercenaries infiltrate the White House, Cale must rescue his daughter and the president, all while navigating a conspiracy that threatens the nation. The film grossed over $205 million and received mixed reviews, with a 52% rating on Rotten Tomatoes.
In contrast, “Olympus Has Fallen,” directed by Antoine Fuqua, features a North Korean terrorist group launching a coordinated attack on the White House. The film’s protagonist, Mike Banning, a former Secret Service agent, must save the president and his son from a group of mercenaries. While the film was successful at the box office, grossing $170 million, its plot raised eyebrows for its implausibility, earning a 50% rating on Rotten Tomatoes.
The sequels to these films further pushed the boundaries of believability. “London Has Fallen” escalates the action to a global scale, with a terrorist attack during a funeral for the British Prime Minister. The film’s premise, involving disguised terrorists infiltrating a high-security event, strained credulity, resulting in a disappointing 28% rating on Rotten Tomatoes despite grossing over $205 million.
“Angel Has Fallen,” the third installment in the “Fallen” series, offers a more grounded narrative. The president is attacked by armed drones while on a fishing trip, and Banning is framed for the assault. This film, while still action-packed, presents a more believable scenario, earning a 39% rating on Rotten Tomatoes and grossing $147 million.
The juxtaposition of these films highlights a critical aspect of storytelling: the balance between excitement and plausibility. While audiences crave thrilling narratives, they also seek a sense of realism that allows them to suspend disbelief. The directors of these films faced the challenge of crafting engaging stories without falling into the trap of absurdity.
In “White House Down,” the plot, while not entirely original, adheres to a set of rules that make it more relatable. The motivations of the characters, the political backdrop, and the unfolding conspiracy create a narrative that, despite its fantastical elements, feels grounded in reality. The film’s success can be attributed to its ability to engage viewers while maintaining a semblance of plausibility.
Conversely, “Olympus Has Fallen” and its sequels often rely on exaggerated scenarios that push the limits of believability. The sheer scale of the attacks and the ease with which the terrorists infiltrate the White House detract from the film’s impact. While action sequences may thrill audiences, the lack of a coherent and plausible narrative can leave viewers feeling disconnected from the story.
The challenge for filmmakers lies in crafting narratives that resonate with audiences while still delivering the adrenaline-fueled excitement that action films promise. As seen in the “Fallen” series, the reliance on implausible plot devices can undermine the tension and engagement that viewers seek.
In conclusion, the directors of “White House Down” and “Olympus Has Fallen” navigated the fine line between excitement and plausibility in their storytelling. While both films offer thrilling action sequences, their differing approaches to narrative coherence highlight the importance of maintaining a believable premise. As audiences continue to crave engaging stories, filmmakers must strive to balance the fantastical with the plausible, ensuring that their narratives resonate with viewers on a deeper level.
Source: Various
